My first kilt was a SWK bought by my wife as a surprise. SURPRISE! Anyway, she was taking my measurements (I had no clue for what) and for a true waist measurement (up at the navel) I measured 44". I know, beer-ish belly... But, when we got the kilt it was too big. We agonized a bit (considering how much too big it was) and decided a 40" would be better fit. We exchanged it for a 40" waist and it fits perfectly--trad style! So what I want to know is, what is your experience with the other kilt makers (well known on the XMTS forum) as far as true measurements.

Let it fly. UK length... USAK hip... whatever. Gimme the specs.

And I'm not dissing SWK by any means. My SWK Irish Nat'l rocks!. It's super well made, fits like a well made suit and is tres comfortable. No complaints--just looking for guidance.