X Marks the Scot - An on-line community of kilt wearers.

   X Marks Partners - (Go to the Partners Dedicated Forums )
USA Kilts website Celtic Croft website Celtic Corner website Houston Kiltmakers

Jacket buttons

Printable View

  • 16th January 08, 07:15 PM
    sblanck
    Jacket buttons
    So my wife is working on my argyll conversion and is sewing on the buttons. She also made my prince charlie. Her question is why three buttons, three on the sleeves three across the pocket flaps. I beleive three on the coat tails of the prince charlie. Anyone know? Thanks


    Sean
  • 16th January 08, 07:23 PM
    thescot
    I guess because there aren't two?
  • 16th January 08, 09:01 PM
    Chef
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by sblanck View Post
    Her question is why three buttons,

    It's all based on mathematics.

    You see three is the first odd prime number, and the second smallest prime. It is both the first Fermat prime (2²º + 1) and the first Mersenne prime (2² - 1), as well as the first lucky prime. However, it's the second Sophie Germain prime, the second Mersenne prime exponent, the second factorial prime (2! + 1), the second Lucas prime, the second Stern prime. Three is the first unique prime due to the properties of its reciprocal. Three is the third Heegner number. Three is the second triangular number and it is the only prime triangular number. Three is the only prime which is one less than a perfect square. Any other number which is n² - 1 for some integer n is not prime, since it is (n - 1)(n + 1). This is true for 3 as well, but in its case one of the factors is 1. Three non-collinear points determine a plane and a circle. Three is the fourth Fibonacci number and the third that is unique. In the Perrin sequence, however, 3 is both the zeroth and third Perrin numbers. Three is the fourth open meandric number. therefore we use buttons in groups of three.

    I hope that helps clear it up for you.
  • 17th January 08, 07:28 AM
    JimB
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Chef View Post
    It's all based on mathematics.

    You see three is the first odd prime number, and the second smallest prime. It is both the first Fermat prime (2²º + 1) and the first Mersenne prime (2² - 1), as well as the first lucky prime. However, it's the second Sophie Germain prime, the second Mersenne prime exponent, the second factorial prime (2! + 1), the second Lucas prime, the second Stern prime. Three is the first unique prime due to the properties of its reciprocal. Three is the third Heegner number. Three is the second triangular number and it is the only prime triangular number. Three is the only prime which is one less than a perfect square. Any other number which is n² - 1 for some integer n is not prime, since it is (n - 1)(n + 1). This is true for 3 as well, but in its case one of the factors is 1. Three non-collinear points determine a plane and a circle. Three is the fourth Fibonacci number and the third that is unique. In the Perrin sequence, however, 3 is both the zeroth and third Perrin numbers. Three is the fourth open meandric number. therefore we use buttons in groups of three.

    I hope that helps clear it up for you.

    Who said tailoring wasn't a science!
    :)
  • 17th January 08, 07:49 AM
    auld argonian
  • 17th January 08, 08:05 AM
    mbhandy
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Chef View Post
    It's all based on mathematics.

    You see three is the first odd prime number, and the second smallest prime. It is both the first Fermat prime (2²º + 1) and the first Mersenne prime (2² - 1), as well as the first lucky prime. However, it's the second Sophie Germain prime, the second Mersenne prime exponent, the second factorial prime (2! + 1), the second Lucas prime, the second Stern prime. Three is the first unique prime due to the properties of its reciprocal. Three is the third Heegner number. Three is the second triangular number and it is the only prime triangular number. Three is the only prime which is one less than a perfect square. Any other number which is n² - 1 for some integer n is not prime, since it is (n - 1)(n + 1). This is true for 3 as well, but in its case one of the factors is 1. Three non-collinear points determine a plane and a circle. Three is the fourth Fibonacci number and the third that is unique. In the Perrin sequence, however, 3 is both the zeroth and third Perrin numbers. Three is the fourth open meandric number. therefore we use buttons in groups of three.

    I hope that helps clear it up for you.

    OK-----Sew???:please:

    MrBill
  • 17th January 08, 08:30 AM
    cavscout
    It's rooted in a philosophy similar to the yin-yang, while 3 is an odd number, there are two (even) sets of buttons to maintain harmony or balance.
  • 17th January 08, 09:35 AM
    Daaaaang
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by Chef View Post
    It's all based on mathematics.


    Dang! You beat me to it. But I figured "at least I can start singing Three is a Magic Number" but then I see:

    Quote:

    Originally Posted by auld argonian View Post

    Dangit you guys you have taken all of my options, daaaaang yooooooou!

    Best,
    Matt!
  • 17th January 08, 10:27 AM
    Chef
    Quote:

    Originally Posted by mbhandy View Post
    OK-----Sew???:please:

    MrBill

    The tongue-in-cheek point we are trying to make is just that it is what it is. Maybe there was some history in the military or elsewhere as to why three buttons was originally chosen, but now it's really just about the style. It just looks right I guess. If you want more or less than three buttons somewhere by all means...

    Of course everyone will snicker at you for not knowing you're supposed to have three buttons. :lol:
  • 17th January 08, 10:35 AM
    turpin
    It's aesthitics. The Japanese do it in Bonsai - Never use an even number of trees in a forest grouping.

    It could have been five buttons, but three is the lowestm and therefore least expensive odd number. Thrifty eh?

» Log in

User Name:

Password:

Not a member yet?
Register Now!
Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v4.2.0