"Freedom" tartan?

**CDNSushi** · 13th September 09, 09:03 PM

I've been considering a kilt made in this tartan. It looks a LOT like Rhode Island's state tartan, I've noticed, and it kinda mimics Isle of Skye in some ways.

Just curious, and I ask this question strictly as a personal opinion to the rabble, and as a matter of taste. Do you like this tartan? Why or why not? Comments?

BTW. Here's a link for GIS for "freedom tartan" if you don't know what it looks like: http://images.google.com/images?hl=e...=f&oq=&aqi=g10

Note: Please refrain from voicing any opinions regarding the Gold Bros., their companies or products. I am fully aware that the Freedom tartan is mainly (although not exclusively) a Gold Bros. item and this thread is not here to discuss their business practices. You are allowed to dislike this tartan because of its purveyor, but let's not go into that too much... If this thread veers in that direction, I'm sure the mods will be watching closely and put the kibosh on it. Thank you for your kind understanding in this regard.

**MacMillan of Rathdown** · 13th September 09, 09:15 PM

Freedom Tartan, as in "freedom from... what?" My take is that it seems kinda bland for something that is supposed to represent freedom. I'd give it a miss.

**Paul** · 14th September 09, 06:32 AM

Originally Posted by MacMillan of Rathdown

Freedom Tartan, as in "freedom from... what?" My take is that it seems kinda bland for something that is supposed to represent freedom. I'd give it a miss.

I think it's a modern/more colour version of the "Freedom of Scotland" tartan. Therefore it is a tartan directed towards Scottish sovereigntism.
(doesn't the name say it all?)

I like the tartan... it's quite different and I had my first and last PV kilt in it. I don't know if I'd get a wool kilt made out of it though. That proably just means I don't LOVE it!

**JRB** · 13th September 09, 09:47 PM

IMO, It's not a bad looking tartan at all, but it certainly doesn't stand out.

**CDNSushi** · 13th September 09, 10:02 PM

Originally Posted by JRB

IMO, It's not a bad looking tartan at all, but it certainly doesn't stand out.

Kinda like the state of Rhode Island? <baddum-pum> <rimshot>

Although to be fair to RI, the sett is a bit different. The Freedom has white stripe on a purple field, whereas the RI has a yellow stripe on a green field.

**Riverkilt** · 13th September 09, 09:58 PM

I agree, the colors seem bland.

For me would depend upon if I already had a similar colored tartan or not. No point in having two kilts with tartans that were nearly the same.

Ron

**beloitpiper** · 13th September 09, 09:59 PM

I like it, but would not buy it. It is very attractive, but I have other things on priority.

**Larry124** · 14th September 09, 12:23 AM

Isn't this the Gold Brothers (former?) "Heritage of Scotland"...?

**English Bloke** · 14th September 09, 01:28 AM

Originally Posted by Larry124

Isn't this the Gold Brothers (former?) "Heritage of Scotland"...?

No, but they do sell it. I quite like it in a quiet sort of way. It looks a bit like the Solway. I'm not buying anymore PV kilts for now and I don't think I'd rush out to buy this in wool.