"Kirking of the Tartans" a recent American Invention?

[davidlpope]

While I was perusing a "Scottish Society" website, I came across a purported origin for the practice of "Kirking the Tartan" that tied it to Scotland during the Jacobite era. That seemed a little questionable, so the best explanation was one that I found was on the Clan Campbell Society (North America) website here:

http://www.ccsna.org/jsep30.htm

Do any of you know of any source documentation for this practice that predates the 1940s in the US?

For those you in Scotland, have you ever heard of this practice?

Cordially,

David

[McMurdo]

David
Some interesting reading here by our own Cajunscot
http://www.scottishtartans.org/kirkin.htm

[davidlpope]

Thanks! I should have known. I think the answer to the meaning of life is posted on the Scottish Tartans Museum website someplace...

Cordially,

David

[M. A. C. Newsome]

Thanks! I should have known. I think the answer to the meaning of life is posted on the Scottish Tartans Museum website someplace...

Cordially,

David

Yeah, but only I have the user ID and password to log into that section of the site. :-)

[Ozark Ridge Rider]

Yeah, but only I have the user ID and password to log into that section of the site. :-)

Ah, but that's what keeps us awaiting your posts with bated breath - sometimes you let a glimmer of it creep in!

[Dall_Piobaire]

Ha...we already have the answer you silly kilted Kaniggit!

[macwilkin]

While I was perusing a "Scottish Society" website, I came across a purported origin for the practice of "Kirking the Tartan" that tied it to Scotland during the Jacobite era. That seemed a little questionable, so the best explanation was one that I found was on the Clan Campbell Society (North America) website here:

http://www.ccsna.org/jsep30.htm

Do any of you know of any source documentation for this practice that predates the 1940s in the US?

For those you in Scotland, have you ever heard of this practice?

Cordially,

David

David,

Glen has already posted my article, but let me just say that all the evidence supports the theory that the service began during the Second World War by Dr. Marshall. The many versions of the "legend" of the kirkin' out there on the Internet are just that -- legend, but as we learned in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, "when legend becomes fact, print the legend."

T.

[piperdbh]

The many versions of the "legend" of the kirkin' out there on the Internet are just that -- legend, but as we learned in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, "when fact becomes legend, print the legend."

T.

Legend? On the Internet? Surely not!


As we learned from Rooster Cogburn in "True Grit", "You can't serve papers on a rat."

[auld argonian]

Legend? On the Internet? Surely not!


As we learned from Rooster Cogburn in "True Grit", "You can't serve papers on a rat."

Of course everything that you find on the internet is true.

Now excuse me while I give this nice man from Nigeria the number of my checking account so he can deposit $5 Million in it....

Best

AA

[Jack Daw]

David,

Glen has already posted my article, but let me just say that all the evidence supports the theory that the service began during the Second World War by Dr. Marshall. The many versions of the "legend" of the kirkin' out there on the Internet are just that -- legend, but as we learned in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance, "when fact becomes legend, print the legend."

T.

Actually, the quote is, "When the legend becomes fact, print the legend..."