Traditional Highland Dress

[Cowher]

When I first joined XMTS I was irritated by the staunch traditionalist who would tell me that the things I liked were wrong because they were not traditional. I looked at the traditional section entitled

Traditional Highland Dress
The place for discussion of Traditional and Classic Highland Apparel and Style. (Basically from the Reign of Edward VII to the 1980's)

I thought to myself who cares what they think. I'm wearing my kilt TODAY. Not in 1901 to 1980's.

I have come to understand that traditional and modern are two terms describing two different styles of kilt style. Both being relevant and worn today.

I was therefor mislead by the title of that subforum and very confused by it. Recently a thread in that subforum has made it known that there are others that feel the way I do about the phrase in parentheses.
There are yet others who fear if the phrase is removed or if the date 1980's was removed it will mislead in the other direction.
Therefor I propose a slight clarification of the subforums title.

Traditional Highland Dress
The place for discussion of Traditional and Classic Highland Apparel and Style. (Originating from the Reign of Edward VII to the 1980's)

Humbly,
Matthew Cowher

[davidlpope]

When I first joined XMTS I was irritated by the staunch traditionalist who would tell me that the things I liked were wrong because they were not traditional. I looked at the traditional section entitled

Traditional Highland Dress
The place for discussion of Traditional and Classic Highland Apparel and Style. (Basically from the Reign of Edward VII to the 1980's)

I thought to myself who cares what they think. I'm wearing my kilt TODAY. Not in 1901 to 1980's.

I have come to understand that traditional and modern are two terms describing two different styles of kilt style. Both being relevant and worn today.

I was therefor mislead by the title of that subforum and very confused by it. Recently a thread in that subforum has made it known that there are others that feel the way I do about the phrase in parentheses.
There are yet others who fear if the phrase is removed or if the date 1980's was removed it will mislead in the other direction.
Therefor I propose a slight clarification of the subforums title.

Traditional Highland Dress
The place for discussion of Traditional and Classic Highland Apparel and Style. (Originating from the Reign of Edward VII to the 1980's)

Humbly,
Matthew Cowher

Are you only making a one-word change? If so, I don't think it's worth the effort.

[CMcG]

I'd suggest simply removing the date range:

Traditional Highland Dress:
The place for discussion of Traditional and Classic Highland Apparel and Style.

[davidlpope]

I'd suggest simply removing the date range:

Traditional Highland Dress:
The place for discussion of Traditional and Classic Highland Apparel and Style.

I'd go for that.

[JSFMACLJR]

I'd go for that.

Me too!

[slohairt]

Me three!

[creagdhubh]

Me too!

Definitely, me as well.

[Downunder Kilt]

I'd suggest simply removing the date range:

Traditional Highland Dress:
The place for discussion of Traditional and Classic Highland Apparel and Style.

If we are going to vote on it, this one got mine.

[Jock Scot]

I'd suggest simply removing the date range:

Traditional Highland Dress:
The place for discussion of Traditional and Classic Highland Apparel and Style.

Yes, me too.


I note that the silence from the powers that be on this subject that has been aired fairly comprehensively now and might I add courteously throughout, is almost deafening.I would be interested on their thoughts on this matter.

[KFCarter]

I'd suggest simply removing the date range:

Traditional Highland Dress:
The place for discussion of Traditional and Classic Highland Apparel and Style.

Looks good to me.