Teflon?

[xman]

I'm looking at a new kilt to wear while dragon boating for next season because my old one is falling off me. I've lost about 5cm (2") off my waist this year and intend to keep it off. I might even shed another 4-5cm next year, but I'm not that concerned about it. My questions to the athletes are;

How important is it to you to have your workout kilt made from one of the Teflon coated range of fabrics (Nevis or Jura) for the extra stain protection? Do you care at all? Do you just suffer the dirt? Is it a problem for you?

I definitely want this made from wool since it was terrifically comfortable paddling in the wool this year, especially when the temperatures weren't too warm. When it gets hot I can wear my PV Casual and the Velcro fasteners means the weight loss isn't as problematic.

What do you say? Should I be worried at all? The inlet water can get pretty grimy in the early summer when the algae is in bloom, but I don't think it's even as bad as a somewhat mucky field might be. I need some experienced folks to weigh in on this for me.

Teflon or move on?

X

[LitTrog]

If I'm understanding the question correctly, the answer hinges upon your priorities. I bought my USAK (teflon-coated) casual hoping that, even after tough-wearing conditions, I could still wear it to pubs and festivals and not look like I did the day before. It has fulfilled those expectations wonderfully. If your preference is wool rather than stain-resistance, I don't have any advice...sorry!

[MacMillans son]

Sorry X I cant speak directly to your question, but I do have an 8 yard PV kilt from Josh that is, of course, a whole different animal than my 4 yard casual kilt.

That may be another option to consider.

And, if you needed the extra lap insulation, with your sewing skills, perhaps doubling the apron thickness would get you really close? Maybe best of both worlds. Just a thought.

Best of luck,
Brooke

[Alan H]

I've never thrown in 100% wool. I have thrown in PV and also in a Fraser and Kirkbright wool/polyester 11 ounce blend 6-yard kilt. Both were just fine.

[Jay]

Teflon has been suggested by some research as being carcinogenic. Personally, I wouldnt want it next to skin that has its' pores open - just in case.

[xman]

Teflon has been suggested by some research as being carcinogenic. Personally, I wouldnt want it next to skin that has its' pores open - just in case.

I'm not in the least bit concerned about this. Indications that such substances might have deleterious carcinogenic effects only appear at temperatures above 350ºC (650ºF). If that happens I'll be more concerned with the certain and imminent third degree burns than the potential cancer.

[CopperNGold]

Just be sure that when turning your kilt, that you use a rubber spatula! Sorry, I couldn't resist!

[Jay]

I'm not in the least bit concerned about this. Indications that such substances might have deleterious carcinogenic effects only appear at temperatures above 350ºC (650ºF). If that happens I'll be more concerned with the certain and imminent third degree burns than the potential cancer.

If my mind was in the gutter I would make a comment on how kilts get women turned on and the "heated" results.

But we, the kilted, are rarely in the gutter.

;-)

[Alan H]

Upshot is, I think you're heading off into an area where nobody but maybe Raphael has any experience. So...go do what seems best. If it works, great. If not, well.....now you know!

[Tartan Tess]

Does anybody know if you can use "scotch guard" on a wool kilt?
Waterproofer for clothing?