Battle royal over Gaelic College name

[Nathan]

This is a very interesting article about our shared History and Heritage and how it impacts modern issues.

Battle royal over Gaelic College name
http://www.capebretonpost.com/News/L...College-name/1

Please be careful with any replies as I don't want the thread to get too political. I thought it was noteworthy though.

Nathan

[ASinclair]

That's a very interesting article. Thanks for posting, Nathan.

[Father Bill]

After a short discussion over a flag, the Moderators have decided to restore this thread to the Miscellaneous Forum. Our apologies for the delay.

Father Bill for the Forum Moderators.

[Chas]

Whatever.
.

[Downunder Kilt]

Best line the whole article - “Good Lord what a tempest in a teapot,” wrote Gordon LaRusic. “So if the Queen provides her coat of arms to HP sauce am I not to eat it?”.

[creagdhubh]

Best line the whole article - “Good Lord what a tempest in a teapot,” wrote Gordon LaRusic. “So if the Queen provides her coat of arms to HP sauce am I not to eat it?”.

I agree! I'm so happy you pointed that out, mate! And Nathan, thanks for sharing the article. Very interesting indeed.

Slainte,

[Nathan]

Chas,

Perhaps I can assist. This is a small local newspaper and everyone local is accustomed to these acronyms and abbreviations, but your point is well taken. MLA is Member of the Legislative Assembly and PC stands for the Progressive Conservative party. Perhaps the writing was unclear but Gaelic is no more "foreign" a language in Nova Scotia or Britain than English ;).

To your second point, I'm not sure about the rumours and innuendo that you are referring to. In my view, they are discussing an official announcement that was made and I think the comments about the historic institutional treatment of Gaelic would stand up to any scrutiny. I also think the public dialogue about the same is what is prompting some people that may not be as well acquainted, to learn their history although having been raised on the island, most people are well versed on the '45 Culloden, Proscription and the Clearances.

From a contemporary perspective, there are certainly two legitimate sides as to whether the historic activities of the Empire and the Province toward Gaelic are sufficient cause for an uproar over this issue in 2013. I'm not taking a position on that here, nor should anyone else (rule #5). I'm just sharing the story because I thought it was very noteworthy for people who may not be aware of the Cape Breton Gaidhealtachd that issues of Highland culture still can make it to modern legislatures and newspapers.

As a point of information, the Gaelic College in question teaches Kilt making, Gaelic language, fiddle, pipes, Highland dancing, step dancing, spinning and other elements of Scottish Gaelic culture. It is a marvelous institution that attracts students and from all over the world.

The current CEO (Chief Executive Officer) of the Gaelic College, Rodney MacDonald who was quoted in the article is also the former Premier (provincial first minister) of Nova Scotia and is a pretty darn good Scottish fiddler and dancer in his own right.

Slàinte,

Nathan

[McClef]

I should point out Chas that Gaelic is NOT a foreign language here in the UK, it is as native as Welsh. :buttkick:

[Dixiecat]

As a point of information, the Gaelic College in question teaches Kilt making, Gaelic language, fiddle, pipes, Highland dancing, step dancing, spinning and other elements of Scottish Gaelic culture. It is a marvelous institution that attracts students and from all over the world.

The current CEO (Chief Executive Officer) of the Gaelic College, Rodney MacDonald who was quoted in the article is also the former Premier (provincial first minister) of Nova Scotia and is a pretty darn good Scottish fiddler and dancer in his own right.

Actually Nathan, the Gaelic College tried to remove highland dancing and bagpipe instruction from it's curriculum a couple of years ago now. It caused quite a controversy in it's own right when the decision was made to do that. At the time, the College said that highland dance and piping was not traditional enough, that since highland dance in the form that it is now, did not come over with the Scottish immigrants, and that competitive piping was not the aim of the College and plenty of venues exist locally in which that avenue of piping could be pursued.

I believe competitive piping is still off the curriculum there, but it's nice to see that highland dance is back.
my original post, some links are extinct:
http://www.xmarksthescot.com/forum/f...-scotia-71516/

It seems that the Gaelic College is finding the road to their new image to be bumpy indeed and while I have no opinion regarding the new name, I think that this gives evidence that the administration is not thinking of the big picture of Cape Breton's Scottish heritage.