Opinions on these hose

[Voussoir]

Hand dyed to match MacPherson tartan, hand spun marl,
100% superwash Merino, knitted in the round, no seams, resoleable foot.
Should I give up now, or knit another pair?

[GlenaladalePiper]

Knit another pair.

[McMurdo]

Keep knitting but wear these well. Great job.

[gsmacleod]

Great job! I would definitely not be giving up!

Shane

[Tobus]

Very unique! Good work. Yes, make more.

[Patty Logan]

Hand dyed to match MacPherson tartan, hand spun marl,
100% superwash Merino, knitted in the round, no seams, resoleable foot.
Should I give up now, or knit another pair?

is this your first time? it would be great to see the evolution of your hose making

[Voussoir]

No, not first time. I’ve knit full fashion dice and argyle, and a crazy pair of border diamonds with split diamonds instead of marl. This is the latest evolution with asymmetrical marl that I drew up to make the main diamonds look different sizes.
The Borders and Splits were a little clownish, but they were for a yarn dealer, not a piper. These are for a piper friend. I’m just wondering if I’m wandering off course or if traditionalists wouldn’t be afraid to wear these in public.

[FossilHunter]

Stunning. I’d wear those with a macpherson tartan kilt.

[Dirty Rogue]

Those look fantastic! You should knit another pair....but to match the Lindsay Ancient tartan....and send 'em my way!!

[Voussoir]

Lindsay would be great with this chart. Border the green with blue, spin red/green and red/blue marl. Use a full red diamond with 2 over check threads spaced 1 stitch apart. A match.