-
19th August 25, 09:16 AM
#1
Locating the Kilt Pin
One always reads that the purpose of the kilt pin is to keep the outer apron in place. I've been watching LOTS of Pipe bands while exercising on an indoors stationary bike (hard to do much else when outdoors it's ≥ 105°F in Las Vegas).
When I visit kilt retailer's websites, I always see the bottom of the kilt pin no more than 2-3 inches above the bottom of the kilt itself, but when I look at military pipe bands in Scotland, they're centered mid-way up the front apron.
Is there some significance to that?
-
-
19th August 25, 09:24 PM
#2
There is no right or wrong place to put the kilt pin. Although the military being the military do have a specific place to put their kilt pin . For the civilian non band member, one wears the pin where it suits the individual. However, it is usual and wise to only put the pin through the outer apron.
" Rules are for the guidance of wise men and the adherence of idle minds and minor tyrants". Field Marshal Lord Slim.
-
The Following 5 Users say 'Aye' to Jock Scot For This Useful Post:
-
20th August 25, 01:49 AM
#3
 Originally Posted by jsrnephdoc
One always reads that the purpose of the kilt pin is to keep the outer apron in place. I've been watching LOTS of Pipe bands while exercising on an indoors stationary bike (hard to do much else when outdoors it's ≥ 105°F in Las Vegas).
When I visit kilt retailer's websites, I always see the bottom of the kilt pin no more than 2-3 inches above the bottom of the kilt itself, but when I look at military pipe bands in Scotland, they're centered mid-way up the front apron.
Is there some significance to that?
Simple answer, yes.
Different kilted regiments developed their own ideas as to where the pin should be located - the Gordon Highlanders appear to wear theirs high on the thigh as they like the pin positioned to cross the middle horizontal green-and-yellow bar of their sett.
The kilt-pin, it should be remembered, is not used to fasten the outer apron the the inner, but to act as a decorative weight for the lower front corner. Almost any kiltie will tell you how well that works...
Unless you are under regimental constraints or in a band or other uniformed body, you are free to place the pin where you fancy - or go without one. Most people find an agreeable part of the sett to place the pin, anywhere from about two inches up from the bottom and a safe distance in from the fringed edge - where the additional folded-back layers help to support the pin. However, you will see old photos of kilties wearing their pins at an angle in the bottom right corner of the kilt, and there in no reason not to do the same if you fancy.
If your kilt-wearing takes you into long grass and undergrowth, or up onto heather moors, it is probably best to do without the pin, as they have an exceptionally annoying habit of attracting brambles and bracken and other long whippy plants with the idea of recreating the Gordian Knot. Consequently, you are for ever trying to disentangle yourself, and are at risk of ripping the pin out of the kilt.
In practice, placing the pin a few inches above the knee is a good idea, as it prevents an irritating knocking against the knee when in action, like walking or dancing.
-
The Following 2 Users say 'Aye' to Troglodyte For This Useful Post:
-
20th August 25, 07:45 AM
#4
 Originally Posted by jsrnephdoc
I've been watching LOTS of Pipe bands while exercising on an indoors stationary bike (hard to do much else when outdoors it's ≥ 105°F in Las Vegas).
About civilian pipe bands, kilt pins aren't all that popular.
To put numbers on it, in Grade One (the bands with the best musicianship, and generally the best-dressed, who are "influencers" amongst lower-level pipe bands the world over) only four of the 14 bands were wearing kilt pins at this year's World Pipe Band Championships last Saturday.
I've played in pipe bands for nearly 50 years now. I've played in a few bands that wore kilt pins and in a few that didn't. From experience I can tell you that there's no "upside" to wearing them, and plenty of "downside".
Bands can wear the same set of kilts for a half-century or more. (One of the Grade One bands, Shotts, got new kilts...in 1983.) The kilts of all the bands who wear kilt pins show damages and stains.
A thing about uniforms is that the more items you add the more things there are to go missing or be worn wrongly. And so it is with kilt pins, it's extremely difficult to get everybody in the band to wear them the same way, and inevitably somebody will lose theirs. So the kilt pins, rather than making the band look more smart, make them look higgledy piggledy.
It's why the preponderance of bands don't bother.
 Originally Posted by jsrnephdoc
When I look at military pipe bands in Scotland, they're centered mid-way up the front apron.
Is there some significance to that?
Sadly because of budget cuts and other causes there are very few military pipe bands in Scotland now.
In 2006 all of Scotland's infantry regiments were coalesced into a single uber-regiment The Royal Regiment Of Scotland.
Every time I look, another one of the battalions' pipe bands has been abolished. As far as I know there's only four left:
2SCOTS
3SCOTS
4SCOTS
7SCOTS
The only battalion whose pipers wear kilt pins is 2SCOTS, here
Last edited by OC Richard; 20th August 25 at 07:56 AM.
Proud Mountaineer from the Highlands of West Virginia; son of the Revolution and Civil War; first Europeans on the Guyandotte
-
-
20th August 25, 08:02 AM
#5
Now if we go back in time, Officers and Pipers of The Gordon Highlanders wore simple blanket pins.
However the Gordon Highlanders ceased to exist in 1994.
Only six kilted Highland regiments existed in the British Army from 1809 to 1948 and the Gordons were the only one to wear kilt pins.
Here's the Gordons' Pipe Major, 2nd from left, the wee gent, in the early 1960s.
The giant of a man at far left, Pipe Major Anderson of The Black Watch, piped at John F Kennedy's funeral.
Last edited by OC Richard; 20th August 25 at 08:13 AM.
Proud Mountaineer from the Highlands of West Virginia; son of the Revolution and Civil War; first Europeans on the Guyandotte
-
-
20th August 25, 08:23 AM
#6
All this legacy stuff aside, you can wear a kilt pin wherever you want.
There does seem to be a traditional range of territory.
It's just common sense; it would look strange to have the pin super high close to the sporran strap, or super low on the selvedge.
And it would look strange to have the pin halfway over to your sporran, or right at the edge touching the fringe.
As mentioned above it's fairly common for men to centre the pin on a stripe in the tartan.
This seems just about right to me.
Last edited by OC Richard; 20th August 25 at 08:28 AM.
Proud Mountaineer from the Highlands of West Virginia; son of the Revolution and Civil War; first Europeans on the Guyandotte
-
The Following User Says 'Aye' to OC Richard For This Useful Post:
-
20th August 25, 08:35 AM
#7
 Originally Posted by OC Richard
About civilian pipe bands, kilt pins aren't all that popular.
To put numbers on it, in Grade One (the bands with the best musicianship, and generally the best-dressed, who are "influencers" amongst lower-level pipe bands the world over) only four of the 14 bands were wearing kilt pins at this year's World Pipe Band Championships last Saturday.
Of course, WHERE to place the kilt pin should be asked in the context of WHETHER. My own collection of kilts remains small enough, and the cost of the pewter trinkets tiny enough (in comparison to the 8 yds of 16 oz wool and the cost of making it into a kilt in the first place, that I've solved the "whether" question by getting one distinct pin per kilt and not moving it around.
But, your marathon of watching the World Piping Championships causes me to ask ANOTHER question: Is it hard to get good tickets for the "Worlds" (online purchases months in advance vs. just buying seats at the gate)? And, if an in person visit isn't possible, how do you go about watching them from the US (do you need a VPN?)
A thing about uniforms is that the more items you add the more things there are to go missing or be worn wrongly. And so it is with kilt pins, it's extremely difficult to get everybody in the band to wear them the same way, and inevitably somebody will lose theirs. So the kilt pins, rather than making the band look more smart, make them look higgledy piggledy.
It's why the preponderance of bands don't bother.
My life in retirement is boring enough that I'm not anywhere close to being a daily kilter, and when I DO wear one, I'm surprised and delighted to see how often perfect strangers ask me intelligent questions. An example: Back in Bozeman, MT, the local symphony orchestra (which is SUPERB, by the way) did a "Movie Music of John Williams" concert. As attendees entered the venue, they were offered a chance to have photos taken with Star Wars characters (no, Jaba wasn't among them). My wife and I joined Chewy and an Imperial Storm Trooper for a portrait. The photog was an MSU undergrad. After he shot the pic, he asked me a question or two about my kilt. So, I started talking about the evolution of the "Lunar 2" tartan and barely got going before he asked "Barb Tewksbury made a kilt for YOU???"
So, I'll keep adding a new pin per new kilt.
Sadly because of budget cuts and other causes there are very few military pipe bands in Scotland now.
In 2006 all of Scotland's infantry regiments were coalesced into a single uber-regiment The Royal Regiment Of Scotland.
Every time I look, another one of the battalions' pipe bands has been abolished. As far as I know there's only four left:
2SCOTS
3SCOTS
4SCOTS
7SCOTS
The only battalion whose pipers wear kilt pins is 2SCOTS, here
Do those military bands participate in the World Championships?
And, two final questions:
The NYC Tartan Day Parade was where I learned there was an iOS app for tuning the drones (pictured in some of the YouTUBE videos of last weekend's "Worlds" now available as well, with the Pipe Major of the winning—wonderful—band doing it for his own group. Is there a similar way of tuning one's chanter? And, if I can gather my sister and sons for an August 2026 "Pipes and Drums" immersion vacation, are there other venues I should consider having on my list besides the Tattoo in Edinburgh, the Worlds in Glasgow, and the UK in Perth (apparently, that contest was canceled this year)?
And, thank you SO much for the lovely photos you often include with your SO informative posts!!
-
-
20th August 25, 08:50 AM
#8
 Originally Posted by OC Richard;1412391The giant of a man at far left, Pipe Major Anderson of The Black Watch, piped at John F Kennedy's funeral.[IMG
https://i.imgur.com/MFIEHwm.jpg[/IMG]
It's truly amazing how MUSIC can put indelible time stamps on our memories.
I don't remember much about either of my own parents' funerals, other than at each, a piper performed Amazing Grace.
And, I remember Robert Kennedy's 1968 funeral primarily because the strings of the Boston Symphony performed the haunting "Adagietto" from Mahler's 5th Symphony. I was still in college then, but that performance cemented a lifelong affection for his symphonic music, including introducing my son, at age 7, to the gargantuan "Resurrection" 2nd (92 minutes long, no intermission). Just over half way through, my son tugged on my sleeve and whispered "how much longer will it last?" We had seats in the very middle of the orchestra at SF's Davies Symphony Hall, as far as one could get from an isle. I assumed his next statement would be that he had to pee or that he was bored, so I asked him "Why? Do we have to leave?" His reply: "No; I don't want it to end."
-
-
20th August 25, 08:55 AM
#9
 Originally Posted by OC Richard
All this legacy stuff aside, you can wear a kilt pin wherever you want.
...
As mentioned above it's fairly common for men to centre the pin on a stripe in the tartan.
This seems just about right to me.

I just realized that I've seen many photos of the king, kilted. In NONE of them is he wearing a hat.
Is it likely he just doesn't like hats, or is there some convention he's honoring?
-
-
20th August 25, 10:53 AM
#10
 Originally Posted by jsrnephdoc
I just realized that I've seen many photos of the king, kilted. In NONE of them is he wearing a hat.
Is it likely he just doesn't like hats, or is there some convention he's honoring?
I've rarely seen photos of him wearing a hat that's not part of a uniform. I would guess if the weather doesn't necessitate a hat, he prefers to do without.
5be9de9948eb1211b20e2ee3.jpeg
-
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|
|
Bookmarks