Michael, I think you look quite sharp. It took me a bit of convincing to try a tattersal shirt with the kilt but it really does work, as does your gingham.

I'll echo what others have said about the sporran chain because I've seen pictures of the wear and tear it can make on the kilt. As for the tucked in tie, I've seen other traditionalists do it but I prefer to knot it to a better length and tuck the skinny end into my shirt.

If ghillie brogues are what you have, then that's what you go with, especially if those are heavy piper's soles and you're intending to tromp around a Highland games. Personally, I prefer to replace the long laces with regular length ones because they look a bit more civilian to me and less like a pipe band. But you ARE a piper, right?