basic brogues

[Tobus]

I am just wondering, if the soles of the "brogues" that you are thinking of getting are a bit too rustic? Why I ask is this, do you really need 4WD type soles for the needs you have in mind? If you do, then fine, but I do wonder if a slimmer sole with a finer tread might be more versitile and therefore more suitable? Just a thought?

I find myself trending more towards Jock's thoughts on this lately. I used to like the look of a chunky sole with thick boot treads. But over time, I started to see it as out-of-proportion with a kilt.

Of course, if you're going to be wearing these in snow, ice, and other environments where such a sole is called for, then obviously you should make the practical decision.

But if it were me, looking for a standard pair of brown brogues that would work for everything from the pub to dinner at my mother's house, I'd probably stick with something that's just a tad dressier. Being brown, they'll look casual anyway, but going with a more dressy style of shoe can help them fit in for occasions where you'll want to look nice without going "dressy" per se.

That said, I have a pair of fairly inexpensive Rockport Almartin shoes which I find to be very comfortable, and suitable for everything from office attire to casual events like Highland Games. Would I wear them through mud or snow? Well, no. But snow is not a concern where I live anyway! Anyway, I think they are a great pair of knock-about shoes, though I wouldn't necessarily want to get them too wet or dirty.

The proportion is right with a kilt, in my opinion. (I'm wearing short spats over them in one picture below, but you get the idea.)