I am not against feedback at all, but I think much of the feedback is at best limited in scope and at worst misleading. As tartans become more and more specialized they apply to a smaller and smaller group. I think that this may become the case with this project.

This is not to say that discussion in general here on XMTS is a bad thing all I am saying is that knowing that someone who is not a Christian is not interested in a Christian tartan is about as useful as knowing that a vegetarian is not interested in joining me for a steak dinner. Imagine if this was a regional or district tartan say for San Francisco, California. Not being a native or even resident of that city and state I would probably not be the target audience. The only advise I could likely offer would be my own aesthetic opinions, but since I would not be a buyer of the resulting tartan, my opinion should probably carry little if any weight in the discussion.