I get the most comments on my "Scruffy Wallace" USA kilt. All women. All saying, "Ooooh I love your skirt!"
Next is my spruce green alt. kilt mini skirt, in which I get, all men saying, "cool kilt!"

It's interesting that the non-tartan one gets the "kilt" comment. Maybe because men are saying it and *they* know it's a man's garment.