Another fine example of what a guy from 2012 wearing a kilt looks like, is our own Jock Scot. Hopefully he doesn't mind me reposting his pics!
Compare Jock's attire to these gentlemen, who look rather less "2012" to me. These may be extreme examples, but there are others looks that are less historical or uniform-like, but that still look too traditional or "not 2012":
Bookmarks