Lots of good posts about Argyll jackets. As I mentioned before, I am wanting to wear one of my kilts to my graduation ceremony in November. I'm on the fence about whether or not I need a jacket. I love the tweed jackets I see folks wearing, but also admire the versatility of the black Argyll jackets. I just haven't been able to commit to buying one or the other. I have a black, five-button waistcoat that I'd like to wear under my gown. If I went with a jacket, I'd probably hire it, so I can continue to sit on the fence... but do I even need one? Thoughts?