Hi there fellow Forrester,

I am in the same situation. I don't particularly like the Forrester Tartan and it doesn't come in many weights, and as you say it's a fairly new design. Where as the Douglas has a rich history. Given the choice if I were to invest in a quality kilt (which I am currently saving for) I would tend to go with the Douglas first and then if finances permitted get the Forrester second. But that is just my opinion.

Welcome aboard.