Tartan Design Feedback

[OC Richard]

What's a relief to my eye is that both your designs are attenuated, with broad expanses and narrow linework.

This was common, I think, in the old days. Most tartans designed nowadays strike me as being overly bulky.

I voted for A. I think it's the best-balanced.

All three are miles better than the vast majority of the ungainly ill-balanced clumsy stuff I see people designing nowadays.