Versatility of the Rob Roy style sporran

[Manu]

As you are asking, to my mind the only place for that style of sporran is on a theatrical film set. I honestly don't think that that style of sporran has a place in the wardrobe of serious kilt attire, even for the most informal of informal kilt events.

Thanks for the input Jock. I often see this style worn by people attending reconnaissance fairs usually wearing some sort of costume related to that era, so I can see the relationship with the theatrical appearance. I have never seen it worn with traditional or contemporary attire, but I was thinking the rest of the outfit would give it less "costumey" appearance.