Let's get real!

[Jock Scot]

This is a kilt website! It's not solely a traditional kilt attire website, its not solely a contemporary kilt website, it's not solely kilt hire website, etc.. We all have our preferences and our likes and dislikes, however those preferences are catered for by having various sections within this website which should cover all points of view and at the moment there is a discussion going on here that is discussing the merits of adding another section, in some form, to cater for a long neglected aspect of kilt attire,on this website.

Yes, kilt hire attire has always been present in the background and because of that it is little understood and because of that it is often criticised unfairly, although there are real issues mainly due to mislabling that do cause worrying misunderstandings.

There are three threads at the moment that illustrate the real differences of view not only from one side of the Atlantic to the other, but also differences of style, so whether we like it or not,there are real differences in styles between one set of kilt attire and another. So pigeon holes and labels are essential to steer conversations to the right place and in consequence a smoother atmosphere for the members is made available to all.

When all said and done, no one kilt style is better than another, different for sure and perhaps more appropriate on occasion, but not better.

Now, if anyone wants advice on traditional kilt attire I may decide to offer advice and opinions and people will do with that advice what they will. Yes, I will and do point out that a wedding picture, for example, posted here as being traditional is actually not in the least traditional. Failing to do so only leads to yet another layer of misinformation. It may be uncomfortable for some but it's the right thing to do in the long run. Misinformation in this modern world is a major blight as it can be spread so easily and quickly.

Generally speaking I have no real interest or knowledge of band kilt attire, kilt hire attire, contemporary kilts, etc., but should I decide to read the threads then that is my choice. BUT, those that actually know what they are talking about should be listened to and yes there always exceptions to most situations so a few things mentioned in good faith do need some latitude!It's the same for every one else with their own particular interests. So pigeon holes and labels are important tools to filter information to the right place but wriggle room is needed to allow for different circumstances. Father Bills excellent current thread in the " putting it on properly" section illustrates the situation perfectly.