how should my argyll jacket fit?

[Steve Ashton]

The stock Argyle jacket from most Scottish based Jacket makers is patterned with a more European fit than Jackets for the N. American market.

It has a bit more taper to the waist. Not quite an Italian cut but the style does not fit the way most Americans are used to jackets fitting.

This styling does not lend itself to guys with a belly. The chest may be the same as your usual size but the waist may be a bit snugger than you are used to.

Many guys find that one size larger than their usual suit jacket size feels better.

But yes the jacket should be able to button. There is no rule that says that just because it is a jacket to be worn with a kilt that it is worn any different than any other jacket. It is just that many leave the jacket open so they do not hide their watch fob and chain.