I would definitely agree that I like #2 the most, but i also agree that I would work at it just a bit more. Maybe change the shade of blue, and like someone else suggested adding a little black line as an accent. I think it looks great though. I would buy one when it's done but my girlfriend would freaking kill me. She's a HUGE ASU fan. Maybe I could just tell her that it's a USA tartan, since it has red/white/ and blue in it.