I'm sorry for the confusion.
They are two different Pipers.
Here are the badges and Tartans of the Scottish Regiments during the Great War, please note that I have placed the badges on the Regiments particular tartans.
Certain Regiments did back their badges with tartan on Tam "O" Shanter's but not all, I have used this method as matter of convenience and will explain as I go along.
Argyll & Sutherland Highlanders (kilted)
Government Sett but was slightly lighter in shade to that of the Blackwatch
No tartan backing was worn with this badge
Blackwatch (kilted)
Government Sett, no tartan backing to this badge, Red Hackle Worn on Tam,
Cameron Highlanders (Kilted)
Cameron of Erracht tartan backed badge
Cameronians (Scottish Rifles) Non Kilted
Douglas tartan backed badge
Gordon Highlanders (kilted)
Gordon tartan backed badge
Highland Light Infantry (Kilted)
Mackenzie tartan backed badge
Kings Own Scottish Borderers
Leslie Tartan backed badge (Non Kilted)
Royal Scots (Non Kilted)
Hunting Stuart tartan backed badge Red centre donates 1st Battalion
Royal Scots Fusiliers (Non kilted)
Government Sett no tartan backing to this badge
Seaforth Highlanders (kilted)
Mackenzie tartan backed badge
More to follow
Regards
Cef
Bookmarks