Hello and a warm from Boston, Massachusetts.
Go for the semi trad., it is a great looking kilt. Rocky has made some great kilts that have been displayed on this forum. Although, I do have to warn you, there is a que for his kilts, and I and many other X-Markers are already in it. There are many activities to be accomplished while in jones mode. I have very highly polished two sets of shoes, two belts, keepers, and day sporran. They will get even more polish before the kilt arrives, as I would rather wait for it to be done in good time, than rush the maker.