OK there seems to be a rallying cry that I should have "dealt with someone with a good reputation, a local kiltmaker, etc." I live in NJ and I have dealt with Matt Newsome and had great experience...he isn't exactly local, and I was referred to him by this site. Now, the kilt fiasco that started this thread...well this company is a SPONSOR of this site. I didn't find anything negative about them, only positive reviews. The company is TartanWeb AKA Scottishkilts.net They have had over 2 weeks to respond and it would seem I will be keeping this kilt. Some of you feel I made an unclear request, however I sent pictures to show exactly what I wanted. The burden of responsibility rests only with the kiltmaker. I believe this is all I wish to say about this matter. Thank you.

-Tom