So I'm contemplating the addition of a "casual" kilt to my collection, preferring to keep my Geoffrey (Tailor) Mackenzie for formal occasions. I'm looking for something versatile that won't break the bank (~$100). I'm not looking for TANK quality, of course, but I'd like to come as close as possible for my price range.

Stillwater's heavy weight looks like a pretty good deal for just over $100, and certainly Jerry seems to have a good reputation on this site.

However, Jaeson's testimony for The Kilted Nation 16oz PV kilt for about the same money has got me in a bit of a bind.

My initial sense is that I'd be just fine either way, but I'd love to hear from anyone with an informed opinion about either (or ideally both) of these kilts: pros and cons, general impressions, etc.

Thanks in advance!