My brother-in-law gave me a few antlers the last time we were there to visit. I have trimmed one to be part of a sgian dubh. Need to find some brass bar stock to finish off the handle.

Anyway, I am looking at the blades from Rab Gordon and Atlanta Cutlery. Just the polished stainless ones. Anyone have experience with both? Opinions as to edge-holding ability, finish, strength, etc?

Will be purchasing two to start, seems to be about the same price either way with shipping (hard to believe as one is coming from Scotland).