Quote Originally Posted by Jock Scot View Post
Before I reply, let me say that this thread has been very entertaining and interesting. I am delighted to note that the "modernists" have not really succeeded in re-inventing the wheel!

Semi -dress sporrans are neither "fish nor fowl" in my book and I do wish that people who don't know what they are buying, would not talk themselves into parting with their hard earned cash thinking they are making a good compromise. In my view they are not. They would be better, by far, to put their money towards a good day sporran and a good dress sporran. In passing, I was not the only one who passed comment on kilt height, hose height and sporrans.
Indeed you were not the only one commenting on kilt height, hose height and sporrans and I appreciate the reminder. These things slipped my mind when I attempted a summary, which speaks to the volume and mass of this thread!

As for a sporran with the outfits in question, are you suggesting a daywear sporran before 6 pm and dress sporran for evening? Anyone else care to chime in? I wasn't able to glean a clear answer or consensus from the thread...