I would like to know why genealogical topics are discussed in a herladry forum. While heraldry and genealogy overlap, the "Gentle Science" of heraldry is something different. A Heraldry Forum should discuss heraldry: ensigns armorial, clan badges, use of heraldry in Highland attire, etc.

I am a great lover of genealogy. If it is felt that there is a need to discuss genealogy in a kilt forum, then why not have a sub-forum dedicated specifically to genealogy, just like there is one for heraldry?