As a first kilt, I think that a custom made PV is a great choice. There are several makers on this site. Rocky @USA Kilts and Steve @ Freedom Kilts come to mind first, but there definitely more. You might want to look at Burnetts and Struth as well. RiverKilt makes two excellent points. First, you want to know who the kilt maker is or at least know that it is made just for you.This allows you to ask questions, resolve problems should they arise and ask more questions. Second, you only get to pick two of the three. QUALITY, PRICE , SERVICE. Don't look for the least expensive that you can find, but buy the best that you can afford. That is the best advice I got from the learned rabble here. So I will say it again.....Buy the best you can afford. You won't regret it.

Here area couple articles that, if you have not read, you may find helpful.
URL="http://www.xmarksthescot.com/forum/f157/side-side-comparison-kilt-fabrics-58373/"]Fabric Choices[/URL]

http://www.xmarksthescot.com/forum/f157/Kilt Style Choices-43530/

That's my $.02, hope it helps.
Let us know what you decide and remember to post pictures!