Quote Originally Posted by Jock Scot View Post
Sigh, and sigh again.

With the greatest of respect to all, this is precisely why if we are going to wear Highland attire, then we really ought to follow the kilt conventions reasonably closely so that in the long run those outwith Scotland will HOPEFULLY begin to understand Highland conventions rather more and not get even more confused by the "incorrect" adaptations that confuse the issue for all concerned.

In fact that applies to a national attire from wherever it hails from, if we choose to wear it..
I agree to a point. My belief is that to gain acceptance among small circles and communities as a whole, Highland attire ought to be introduced to people in a way that piques interest, shows respect for both traditions, and isn't shocking or startling to the extent of leaving folks with a bad taste in their mouth.

I never intended to suggest that anybody incorrectly adapt traditional Scottish dress, but that they work within the tradition to find a suitable middle ground for introducing people (hosts and guests) to the kilt and all that goes with it. The analogy of boiling frogs comes to mind...

Am I incorrect in my thinking that a grey waistcoat and striped or solid tie would not be correct to wear with a silver-buttoned black Argyll jacket?