Cameron of Erracht appropriateness

[Grizzly]

I don't think so Jock, Lochiel was present when McLean of Dochgarroch stated that it was acceptable to wear Cameron of Erracht and also Duncan Cameron, Clan Cameron commissioner wears it without reproach. However what is in Lochiels mind we will never know unless he makes a contradictory statement.

Perhaps, if the opportunity arises at your next shoot, you might pose the question. If you do I will make sure the Test is full of salmon for your next visit.

[TheOfficialBren]

Simon, thank you for posing the question to Lochiel.

Officially unifficial or unofficially official. Classic.

I will have to give this one some more thought.

[ThistleDown]

To back up what Grizzly said: The Very Rev Alan Maclean of Dochgarroch is the son of the late Loraine Murray (Calvert) Maclean of Dochgarroch, who was the great, great, great grand-daughter of Sir Alan Cameron of Erracht. She was president of the Inverness Field Club, the first female president in its 150+ years, I believe. She was author of -- among other writings --'Ìndomitable Colonel', the biography of her ancestor, the sole founder and first Colonel of the 79th, the Cameron Highlanders.

It is, of course, Lochiel who declares which tartans are acceptable to him as the Cameron chief and not a Maclean or a Cameron commissioner, but I strongly suspect that Dochgarroch will have had his agreement prior to making that statement. Mind you, I would like to see it in writing by Lochiel somewhere

[Grizzly]

Rex thank you very much for the background info, I did not know of quite where McLean of Dochgarroch fit into the picture.

Maybe I have sparked a little thought in Duncan Cameron's mind to raise the question with Lochiel at some point, but I won't hold my breath.

[ThistleDown]

I don't know Duncan Cameron, Simon, or his relationship to/with Lochiel, but in the absence of 'official' word from Himself we may want to go with what you heard Dochgarroch say with your own ears (?) and what Jock has seen with his own old eyes. Keeping in mind, of course, that the late Sir Donald was Honourary Colonel of a territorial battalion of the Queen's Own Highlanders (the amalgam of the Camerons and Seaforths) from the late 60s and it may just have been in recognition of that honour that he wore the trews Jock saw him in.

[Jock Scot]

Just to be clear I am talking about the present Lochiel(who, I am pretty sure, served in the TA as a young man). If you want to see the trews for real, so to speak, see if you can google "Castle Commando" an interesting BBC(I Think)TV program about the Commandos and Achnacarry. Somewhere in there you will see the present Lochiel talking to a retired Royal Marine Major about times past----and the tartan trews.