Nice post Jimmy!
It confirms my observations as far as traditional wear goes.
It seems to me that what is called a traditional kilt is taken from one point in history and steadfastly referred to as traditional. There are traditions that date farther back than this time but they are largely disregarded.
All the talk of what is proper to wear with the kilt, or even which pleating and pattern is used, is largely fabricated to convince people to buy the more expensive kilts on the market. It is a very successful marketing ploy. Just look at how many people, (even well meaning people), will correct you if you don't wear your kilt exactly the 'proper' way.
I have been saying exactly this sort of thing since I started Bear Kilts.
Kilts were originally garments worn however the wearer pleased. Don't let anyone tell you something else!
If it is sometimes hard to wear a kilt in this age of pants, can it be much harder to wear a non-traditional kilt? If the truth is difficult, is it any less true?