I havent had an Amerikilt but I have had 2 UTs.
If you have no kilts & would like to get at inexpensive kilt they are good. The stitching on mine was some what dicy. They were both labeled as poly cotton but 1 was obviousle brushed cotton. One a personal level UT is a great company to deal with. Their kilts are made in Pakistan modelled after the RKilt hemp kilts.