The only kilts I have to compare the philibeag to are my 8yd Bearkilt, and a Sportkilt I bought two years ago. The philibeag is a little lighter than the Bearkilt, although the PV seems to be about the same thickness. It is way heaver than the Sportkilt. I probobly won't be wearing the Sportkilt anymore! The pleating is great, not as Deep as the 8yd but very nice. They have a great swing to them. I'll try to get some pictures posted soon!