The ideal time for the black argyll

[creagdhubh]

I am not sure that there is an ideal time for the black barathea Argyll jacket. As you say for day events tweed is preferable and for evening a coatee or doublet would be the preferred choice. I do not own one, and have thought about purchasing one, however I have not needed to as I have tweeds for the day and other more appropriate choices for evening wear.

That's precisely where I stand as well, Glen. I have always thought the Argyll style jacket and waistcoat in black Barathea wool as being rather superfluous and may been seen as more along the lines of the "pipe band look." I know many retailers label it as "semi-formal," which is a term that has never made much sense to me anyways. Again, just my two pence for what it's worth. I realise that not everyone can afford doublets and coatees cut for black/white tie affairs when Highland dress is worn, so an Argyll jacket in black Barathea may be a more realistic (versatile perhaps?) option/alternative.

In previous threads, I do believe Jock Scot has gone into great detail in regards to the Argyll style jacket in black Barathea/silver buttons and when/where it's worn.

Cheers,