Which tartan for MacClive?

[figheadair]

[QUOTE=Nathan;1233352]So, I sent an email to Houston traditional kilt makers who list MacClive as a sept of Stewart of Appin, and asked for his source. This is a relevant excerpt from his reply:

Hi Nathan,
Yes, it is a sept of Stewart this is the work of Dr. Philip D. Smith phD, fsic, gts, fsa scot, past Governor of the STA tartan. For me, I class him as god on tartan.

Oh dear . History based on local phone books!