Quote Originally Posted by episcopalscot
Hmm...what about Saffron Irish Kilts, Hodden Grey (for the London Scottish) and Tweed kilts -- all three have been around for some time, the first two since the mid 19th century at least.

These three should not be lumped in with "contemporary" kilts because of their history.
Just my opinion.
Hadn't thought of those. Good point. It also seems to me that the deeper point you subtly make is that in order to divide our forums into rigid categories, we would have to come to agreement on what exactly defines each style. Look at us. Fat chance. And having more specific rules for which kilts are allowed in which forum probably wouldn't solve potential misinformation; only being outspoken about our individual opinions of and experiences with different kiltmakers will.