T-Shirts with kilts - to tuck or not to tuck ?

[Chaps]

I always tuck since I wear a belt and sporran with even my casual and hiking kilts.

[crsbryan]

For me:
The kilt just doesn't feel right unless the t-shirt, polo, or dress shirt is tucked in.
(How else would you show off your waist plate?)
Sweatshirts and sweaters stay out.

[kiltedrennie]

Well, I wear a t-shirt untucked most of the time when wearing jeans.

When I wear a t-shirt with a utility kilt, it's usually untucked. Unless I'm wearing a hoodie, sweater, or sweatshirt.

I find that I'm wearing my utility kilt most of the time for extreme casual wear. I'll still wear the traditional kilt casually, but it's with a t-shirt tucked in with a polo shirt (tucked in), button down oxford (tucked in), or sweater (untucked).

[NUist]

I think my preference would be to tuck. Although that would also depend on how skinny I was feeling that day.

[tripleblessed]

Always tuck. Always. Period. I am perceived as non-traditional here because I'm almost always in
T-shirts and moccasins, but I'm pretty traditional. Just unconventionally so. I don't go out to pick
up the newspaper without my shirt tucked. Or to break up a dog fight.

One decides for self what to wear, but an untucked shirt is just sloppy, slovenly, and visually bothersome.
Having a nonstandard body, I have mostly worn T-shirts, so the issue has come up with a wide variety
of age, economic, and educational groups. Virtually unanimous disapproval for untucked. Plus, it just
screams, "No, I don't have any respect for you or anyone else. Not even me."

And yeah, I'm old.

[jetstar63]

I tuck all shirts in. To me, it looks better to show the belt off.

[kiltedrennie]

One decides for self what to wear, but an untucked shirt is just sloppy, slovenly, and visually bothersome.
Having a nonstandard body, I have mostly worn T-shirts, so the issue has come up with a wide variety
of age, economic, and educational groups. Virtually unanimous disapproval for untucked. Plus, it just
screams, "No, I don't have any respect for you or anyone else. Not even me."

And yeah, I'm old.

I find your statement just as unpleasant. “I was just kidding!", "Can't you take a joke?”, and "Yeah, I'm old" are just an excuse for being rude.

[KiltFitz]

I'm very fat but if it's a t-shirt I still tuck usually. Except tonight. Tonight I let it all hang out just for the hell of it. Nobody seemed to notice, let alone care. they certainly weren't offended.

I'm a much snappier dresser now than I was in my youth and yet my sloppy moments are even more slovenly and dishevelled than I was ever capable of when I was a rude, bothersome and unpleasant teenager. It must be the company I keep.

[ratspike]

Plus, it just
screams, "No, I don't have any respect for you or anyone else. Not even me."

And yeah, I'm old.

Seriously? An untucked tshirt means I have no respect for myself? This kind of crap is exactly why I rarely spend time here. I know plenty of old dudes who don't have that kind of toxic attitude, so I think you probably just suck.

[Catharps]

Well, that escelated quickly.jpg

I favor a tucked in clean look myself.