While researching early 19th century Scottish clothing, I have run across some rather questionable attempts by non-Scots at Scottish costumes, so I thought it would be fun to make silly poll out of them.

Poll:
Which of these 3 early 19th c. "Scottish" costumes is the worst?

1. The Bavarian who couldn't find any tartan and thought ribbons were a good substitute for hose.
Click image for larger version.  Name: King Ludwig’s costumed quadrille 1835.jpg  Views: 9  Size: 79.3 KB  ID: 44024
"Scottish" costume worn for King Ludwig’s costumed quadrille in 1835.

2. The French opera singer with mini-skirt and a sporran bigger than his head.
Click image for larger version.  Name: Petite galerie dramatique MacGregor 1822-1843 small.jpg  Views: 8  Size: 147.4 KB  ID: 44025
Costume design for the character of Mac-Gregor [sic] in 'La Dame du Lac' (The lady of the Lake) 1822-1843

3. This English theater costume for Rob Roy Macgregor
Click image for larger version.  Name: Thomas James Serle as Rob Roy Macgregor 1830s-40s.jpg  Views: 8  Size: 91.2 KB  ID: 44026
Thomas James Serle as Rob Roy Macgregor 1830s-1840s. He has a bunch of Roman-inspired elements: laminar shoulder armor, a shield that looks more like a clipeus than a targe, and gladiator sandals, to make the outfit look historical, I guess.