Variations on the traditional kilt.

[James]

On a regular basis I wear two variations:

The hillwalker and for warmer weather the 'Gentleman's'.

They in fact are my day to day kilts-and I have worn them for all occasions up to demi-formal: and certainly for informal highland events/social occasions.

The point of this post is to mention that though both variations are obviously no traditional-I have never had other than a positive comment.

Which suggests that even when amid those who take the kilt and the 'right' tartan very seriously, there is an acceptance of innovation and sensible development.

James

James

[M. A. C. Newsome]

James,

Usually when I hear the phrase, "gentleman's kilt" the person is referring to the standard men's kilt -- eight yards of worsted wool tartan knife pleated, hand tailored, etc.

You seem to be using it to refer to a more casual style of kilt, like the Hillwalker. If there a company offering a different style? Enlighten us!

Aye,
Matt

[Jimmy Carbomb]

The point of this post is to mention that though both variations are obviously no traditional-I have never had other than a positive comment.

Which suggests that even when amid those who take the kilt and the 'right' tartan very seriously, there is an acceptance of innovation and sensible development.

The key phrase that you use is "sensible development"... and it's something that's well understood by all here. In my own, personal opinion the "Boxer" type kilt that UtiliKilt is selling is over the line. That's MY opinion. The "mocker and "workman's" are a great alternative... and I own them. BearKilts' "Grizzly Cut" is another one that's close to the look but tasteful enough to be acceptable to the "kilt police". For the most part, the kilt makers in North America call their products EXACTLY what they are... casual, semi-traditional, and the few that are authentic traditional hand-sewns.

IF you should ever come across those that are NOT accepting:

Merely explain to them that you're honoring the culture and traditions of the Celts without infringing on their authentic garments. You would rather promote the heritage with these garments, rather than possibly insult someone by donning an authentic. Your choice is one of appreciation rather than confrontation.

I recommended this to an old customer that had to deal with the "authoritarians" at some Festivals and Games. He's used it the few times that he had to and was responded to with gratitude rather than angst.

[macgreggor]

IF you should ever come across those that are NOT accepting:

Merely explain to them that you're honoring the culture and traditions of the Celts without infringing on their authentic garments. You would rather promote the heritage with these garments, rather than possibly insult someone by donning an authentic. Your choice is one of appreciation rather than confrontation.

I recommended this to an old customer that had to deal with the "authoritarians" at some Festivals and Games. He's used it the few times that he had to and was responded to with gratitude rather than angst.

nice reply jimmy,
mind if i use it if and when the oppurtunity arises?
macG

[James]

To answer your question Matt.

There was-I've not heard of them for a few years a firm-but they might be still operating who made a kilt variant called 'The Gentleman's Kilt'. The were a one off firm who saw a niche in the market.

With only four pleats at the back-albeit very deep-and full aprons + pockets, it is much lighter and cooler than either a traditional or hillwalker. Whilst being of the 'right' tartan-I find I can get away with it for less formal occasions.

Very practical and much cheaper-at about £100 as opposed to the nearly £400.

James