My vote would be yes, I think the thread history shows that something like this would be beneficial. I don't think it would result in being "taken over" since we're talking more about guests reviewing the threads.

The downside, I'm cynical, is that my wife, who could probably give excellent advice on this, is not likely to post. She is more from the "give your head a shake, girl" school of thought on this. To her, a kilt is fairly natural, and "so what?". Any objection is more fashion, she would rather see the heavy socks and the Jacobite shirt but...she prefers kilt, tee, and sandals to jeans and stray cats/rolling stones tees.

The other thing is that a really cynical person knows every woman on a board is really that fat comic book guy from the Simpsons. (but, hey, pirate kitty, I don't believe that.)