Daneel, I am not quite in the same boat as you - both my original "X Marks..." kilt pins are still in good order, but those pins on the back are very poor and don't allow the decorative part to lie flat on the kilt fabric - they droop! I am still trying to devise a means of overcoming that.

As for your broken pin: I can suggest only that you look out for an inexpensive piece of jewellery with the right sort of pin on the back. Wrench off that pin and superglue it on the back of the "X Marks...." one. I am keeping my eyes open for just such items, but I'm not sure how easily the old pins can be removed from our fine "X Marks..." items without damaging the fronts. Guess brute force is the only way!

Has anyone else solved the 'droop' problem?