|
-
4th November 05, 01:02 AM
#1
The standards are at half-mast.
But, sadly the BBC created a pale pastiche of Compton McKenzie's masterpiece.
I never got over the loss of Hector, a completely barking but loveable character.
The loss of the original cast (who turn up in cameo roles) and the inclusion of "viewable" actors, diminished the series for me.
What's next? A series based on that wonderful black and white film: Whisky Galore! ?
What else will they try and ruin next?
-
-
4th November 05, 01:33 AM
#2
I loved watching "Two Thousand acres of Skye" has anyone else seen it . Theres no kilts but lots of fun characters
-
-
28th November 05, 09:55 AM
#3
I'll miss MOTG as much as the next person... but I have to say that after the departure of Archie, Lexie, Kilwillie, Duncan, and Hector... it would appear that the show really needed to go.
The characters of Paul, Ewan, Donald and Isobel weren't enough to do justice.
Of all of the varied characters, I'll miss the taciturn and wise Golly, most of all.
-
-
28th November 05, 10:16 AM
#4
 Originally Posted by Kilted Gunfighter
I'll miss MOTG as much as the next person... but I have to say that after the departure of Archie, Lexie, Kilwillie, Duncan, and Hector... it would appear that the show really needed to go.
The characters of Paul, Ewan, Donald and Isobel weren't enough to do justice.
Of all of the varied characters, I'll miss the taciturn and wise Golly, most of all.
Ah now, I could have watched Isobel with the sound off and still enjoyed her scenes 
Ewan annoyed me, but I thought Donald was a bit of fun. I agree though, once the main cast started to leave the show went down hill.
As a side note, has anyone else read Compton MacKenzie's novel "Monarch of the Glen"? I have read MOTG and am waiting for the Rival Monster and Ben Nevis Goes East to arrive so I can read those as well.
I loved Whisky Galore and will have to finish that series next.
-
-
28th November 05, 01:19 PM
#5
my dad has the first three seasons! and i am slowly watching them... alas all good things must come to an end .......... damn
-
-
28th November 05, 04:10 PM
#6
So, Colin, where did you manage to find any of the books? I've been looking around here (Chicago) and on the 'net and haven't had much success.
best
AA
-
-
28th November 05, 04:13 PM
#7
 Originally Posted by auld argonian
So, Colin, where did you manage to find any of the books? I've been looking around here (Chicago) and on the 'net and haven't had much success.
best
AA
Todd reminded me about interlibrary loans. Basically your local library can import books from any ohter library. I looked for them for sometime, but than went the library route. Entertaining books.
-
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|
|
Bookmarks