Need help and/or advice

[caig]

The Granite without doubt in my humble view.

[M. A. C. Newsome]

I'd definitely go with the Highland Granite. The saltire kilt is nice, but seems rather "faddish" to me. In other words, when you celebrate your 40th anniversary, your Highland Granite kilt won't seem dated. :-) Go with the one that will be in style a generation from now.

Matt