I think it is the best working clasp I have. I have another sporran with a weighted top and a snap that is worthless as far as staying closed. I also have a RobRoy style that uses a leather monkey fist knot to hold it shut. It works, but is kind of a pain to cinch up when you close it.

The pin style clasp on this new sporran holds tight and is easy to get in and out of.

I give it 2 thumbs up.