USA Casuals vs. Stillwater Standard?

[Jimmy Carbomb]

Before you take any more information about the Stillwater kilts from anyone that really doesn't know the construction or the fabric... please ask them. The 2006 line will put the thumbscrews to many of the complaints that some have voiced (wrong or right).

You also need to understand the authenticity of the tartans (certain ones are more important than others) and who does and who does not have the licensing to create and sell them. Some tartans are "just off" the standard, while others are the "real deal". Look at the 2006 Stillwater line... compare pricing with them and every maker (solid and tartan)... look at the styling... then decide.

Don't forget to check with the formal-wear and Scottish shops for rentals. Those are top quality in make and fabric for a "song". It's a way that I've bought three times now, and every one is a bargain beyond a bargain.

[mudd]

I've got one of each.
The Stillwater is a nice traditional looking kilt, but not tailored. The length and the taper from waist to hips might not fit just right depending on your measurements. In my case, I need to wear the stillwater a little high because I really need a 22” length.
The USA, on the other hand, fits perfect. It sits right on my waist and is just the right length. I wish it had buckles instead of velcro, but the attention to detail is flawless. The apron is cut so the pattern is perfectly symmetrical. It is cut wider at the bottom so it doesn’t curl out (something the stillwater does). The pleats line up perfectly.
Of course, the stillwater is comfy and has more fabric. And, of course, the Velcro on the USA makes it easier to put on and off.
I like them both. Maybe you should just get one of each and tell us which one you like best.

[GlassMan]

Remember, the velcro is only on the USA casual. It's still buckles on the Semi-Trad and Premier.

[Ranald]

Hi Glen and thanks.
I've have only worn "tradition" tailored kilts and great kilts-all 100% heavies, I would like something to beat around in, working in the yard etc...

I really like both.

dave

Dave have you not thought about wearing the philabeg, 4 yards and maybe put some stitches in , some one called this a cheater I think.
What do people think about this alternative ?

[mudd]

Remember, the velcro is only on the USA casual. It's still buckles on the Semi-Trad and Premier.

Yeah, but at twice the price, or more. I'll probably get one or the other of those in the future. I wish the USA Semi-Trad came in a few more Tartans (like Leatherneck or MacIntosh).
Still, you can't beat SW for the price.