There were a lot of problems with the review topic, and although I did like it, I do think it was starting to cause some dissent among members. Now, most newbies have the good sense to ask, "what do you think of this kiltmaker or vendor". and they get a quick answer as well as good advice. There is only one vendor which I ever had complaints about, and I make sure to PM the details to anyone I see who is contemplating purchasing from them. The review thing might work better if it could be set up with just a company name, and a selection of yes or no, with no place to editorialize about them. Then members could look and see a rating similar to Ebay's system