A little slice of Highland clan history

[Pour1Malt]

excellent!

ta fur that!

[Tattoo Bradley]

That's pretty interesting

[pdcorlis]

Thanks for posting this Scott - I think its always interesting to understand the real history of the highland clans.

[Scott Gilmore]

Thanks for posting this Scott - I think its always interesting to understand the real history of the highland clans.

Agreed. There are two aspects of this that I find particularly interesting. First, what we now understand as the Highland clan system is a somewhat "new" concept. Clan Morrison has only existed for about 1,000 years, but clearly my ancestors in that region have a much longer history. Also, I'm no historian, but I would imagine that the clan concept as we know it now has evolved considerably along with the use of family names.

Second, tartans as used by our ancestors were not regarded the way they are today. I read somewhere recently that very few Outer Hebrides Scots actually own a kilt or any garment made from "their" tartan. I can't attest to the accuracy of these statements, but considering the very traditional, conservative lifestyle generally attributed to the area, and from all accounts the warm, close knit nature of these Highland communities, it isn't surprising that the need simply isn't there for the pomp and tradition that many North Americans and others who no longer live in the heart of Scotland seem to find comfort in. After all, they live it every day.

Having said that, there is by all appearances a resurgence in Highland games in islands many communities. I wonder: Has the self-image of the Highland Scot been influenced by those that left - some of them hundreds of years ago?

Anyway, Carol and I plan to get a first hand look at all this some day soon (we hope). Plenty to think about though in preparation for our visit.

Regards,
Scott Gilmore

[macwilkin]

Having said that, there is by all appearances a resurgence in Highland games in islands many communities. I wonder: Has the self-image of the Highland Scot been influenced by those that left - some of them hundreds of years ago?

Recommended reading on this subject: Celeste Ray's Highland Heritage: Scottish Americans in the American South. (U. of North Carolina, 2000).

Cheers,

Todd

[pdcorlis]

Recently I've been reading The Scottish Highlanders a personal view by Charles MacKinnon - recommended by a fellow XMarker. There, he states that the number of identifiable highland "clans" at the time just prior to Culloden was between forty and fifty - far different than the "modern" history of clans and tartans after the great tartan revival of 1822. It's fascinating (for me at least) to understand and appreciate the full sweep of history for the highland clan system.

[macwilkin]

Recently I've been reading The Scottish Highlanders a personal view by Charles MacKinnon - recommended by a fellow XMarker. There, he states that the number of identifiable highland "clans" at the time just prior to Culloden was between forty and fifty - far different than the "modern" history of clans and tartans after the great tartan revival of 1822. It's fascinating (for me at least) to understand and appreciate the full sweep of history for the highland clan system.

MacKinnon is good as well. He dispells some of the myths of Highland History.

I also recommend Ian Grimble's Clans and Chiefs.

T.