Is there a need for a low-cost kilt roller?

[phil h]

I like the idea of the folding chair bag, but I think it may not be stiff enough, the rolled kilt will just flop.

[Kilted KT]

based on the previous post, the one I am designing will be semi-rigid. It won't be solid, like a plastic case, but will have a stiffener sewn in to prevent it from just flopping over like a wet noodle.

[turpin]

I like the idea of the folding chair bag, but I think it may not be stiff enough, the rolled kilt will just flop.

That was my thought too, if the bag is used alone. But if encased in a tube, such as a nylon stocking, orthopaedic webbing (stretchy elastic/cotton used in casting) or the drainage tubing I mentioned above, I think the kilt wouldn't flop - the "casing" would help maintain the rolled shape and the stuff sack functions as the carrier and an extra layer of protection.