plain black sporran acceptable for 'formal'?

[Cawdorian]

I just responded to another post on a smilar subject. I have a plain black Country Sporran (the only one I have) with the pewter fob. I have worn it with my black Argyle Jacket and black tie. I don't know whether it is "correct" or not, but I've never had the tartan police after me because of it. The Country Sporran seems to be quite popular with our group, Has anyone else worn theirs with black tie?

[Bob C]

I wouldn't do it, Moose. You can pick up an inexpensive dress sporran on Ebay.

http://search.ebay.com/search/search...=dress+sporran

[billmcc]

I think you need a sporran with a metal cantle to go with a PC. How about something like this:
http://www.sportkilt.com/departments...ss-sporran.cfm

It is made of black leather and has a metal cantle. It is more conservative looking than a standard dress sporran with a fur pouch. This type of sporran is also sold on E-Bay.